Welcome to Pizza Mill & Sub Factory (Alamogordo)
Pizza Mill & Sub Factory in Alamogordo offers a delightful culinary experience centered around their thin, crispy pizzas and scrumptious subs. Located at 1315 E 10th St, this eatery excels in flavor, allowing the fresh toppings and savory sauces to shine through with every bite. Customers rave about the standout roast beef and Italian subs, complemented by tangy vinaigrettes. While the service is efficient, diners recommend a friendlier touch. Despite limited parking, the charm of this restaurant makes it worthwhile. Whether you're craving a pie or a sandwich, Pizza Mill ensures a memorable meal in a cozy ambiance.
Pizza Mill & Sub Factory (Alamogordo): Reviews & Ratings
I love their pizzas! The crust is relatively thin and crispy, but not dry. Great choice of toppings. Customer service could be friendlier, but it’s never been bad. There is virtually no parking in front of the restaurant so, you’ll probably have to street park on Oregon Ave. and walk over to the restaurant. I recommend this location.
We picked up some sandwiches, and they were delicious . I had the roast beef, and it came with a vinaigrette yum, and my husband had the Italian sub. He loves it. We will have to try the pizza next! Enjoy!
Pizza were thin and crispy. The pizza tasted really good. Customer service was very good and quick. It was very quiet and not noisy at all. Served four 16" pies fairly quickly.
outstanding and worth the drive. we special ordered one and we got the garbage barge and they were fantastic.
Best pizza ever. I love being able to taste all the toppings and sauce rather than too much bread, and this pizza delivers that experience beautifully. Staff is personable and helpful, and they will step up and go above and beyond if any error occurs with your order. Wish we had pizza places like this at home!
Super cute and great food! If you love little local hole in the wall places with great atmosphere this is it. Nice people, and everything we had was delicious. Our group had subs, salad, kids nuggets, and pizza. I love the decor. Definitely check this place out!
Long story short, we got here with only 30 minutes until close on 3/25/25. Which if you know me, I would normally NEVER do but (who I think was) the manager was so nice and let us in and order anyway, Togo of course! So even though I’m posting this so late I wanted to let him know that we much appreciated it or we would’ve missed out on this amazing dinner!
Very cute local place! We ate here twice while staying in Alamogordo. The first time we had subs which were excellent, so we came back again and had their pizza- also excellent! The people working there were very nice too.
Location
-
1315 E 10th St, Alamogordo, NM 88310, United States Hotline: +1 575-434-1313
Welcome to Pizza Mill & Sub Factory, an inviting eatery nestled in the heart of Alamogordo, NM, at 1315 E 10th St. Known for its mouthwatering pizzas and delicious sandwiches, this dining spot promises a fulfilling culinary experience for both locals and visitors alike.
One of the standout features of Pizza Mill is its thin and crispy crust, which has received rave reviews from patrons such as TJ Smooth and Ajit Patel. Many have praised how the crust strikes a perfect balance—not too dry, allowing the flavors of fresh toppings to shine through. The diverse selection of toppings ensures that there's something for every palate, promising a delightful journey for pizza lovers.
Not to be overlooked are their sandwiches. The rave reviews from customers like Sylvia Koelsch highlight the tasty roast beef and Italian sub, bringing versatility to the menu. With dishes like these, your visit is bound to spark curiosity for more, perhaps even leading to a pizza pass after savoring those sandwiches.
The overall experience at Pizza Mill extends beyond the food. Guests such as Christina Davison have noted the friendly and helpful staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. While parking may pose a minor challenge—with limited spots available directly in front—many find the short walk worthwhile for the exceptional food awaiting them.
Recently praised for their signature pizza, aptly named Garbage Barge, customer Givon Wayne Gilliam referred to it as "outstanding and worth the drive." This culinary gem proves to be a treasure for those who seek both quality and flavor in their meal.
Overall, Pizza Mill & Sub Factory is not just a restaurant; it is a destination for flavor enthusiasts. The combination of a relaxed atmosphere, quick service, and a menu brimming with choices makes it a must-visit in Alamogordo. So, come hungry and ready to discover your new favorite pizza or sandwich, and enjoy every moment at Pizza Mill!